Sunday, 23 October 2016

Gardena Robotic Lawn Mower Review

We have owned the Gardena R40Li robotic lawn mower since I started this blog, back in 2013. In fact, one of the reasons I started the blog was to share my experiences and decision process, and as such now feels like the time is right to write a full Gardena robotic lawn mower review, having lived with the beast for three seasons.

For those who don't have time to read the full review, here are the bullet points. First, the good:
  • The grass has never looked better;
  • I got time back to do railway modelling instead;
  • The whole experience has been almost pain-free.
Now, the not-so-good:
  • Yes, it was expensive;
  • Yes, parts fail (if you don't take care of it);
  • Yes, moving the perimeter wire can be a pain.
The conclusion -- I would buy it again, but I'd take better care of it (i.e. clean it properly) and set it up a bit differently, probably getting in an expert to do that with me. After all, they did offer a free consultation!

Gardena Robotic Lawn Mower Installation

Installing the mower looked so easy on the DVD that came with it that I decided to go it alone, despite the kind offer to have someone come and help me install the perimeter wire (for free). One Sunday afternoon, instead of actually mowing with the old petrol-fired behemoth that it was to replace, I got stuck into the installation process.

The R40Li comes with it's own charging station, which sits on a perimeter wire, which stops the robot going off and mowing the tulips and neighbours drive when it should be doing the lawn. There's also a kind of follow-me cable that hooks up the mid-point of the perimeter wire to the charging station.

The idea is that, if the robot runs out of juice, it can find the wire, and subsequently find its way home. This is a system that works very well, but also has a dual use, as the wire can also be followed to a hard-to-reach part of the garden in case the mower is in danger of missing it due to a narrow entrance.

This is, in fact, something I regret not having done. 

Instead, my return loop is just a straight line. Having connected everything up and left it there for three years, I'm wary of upsetting the apple cart by relocating it, and probably the professional installer would have spotted my error straight away!

Other than that, once everything was in place, pinned down with the black plastic pegs and connected with waterproof 3M connectors (all supplied in the box), and plugged into my outside plug socket -- note, this is indispensible -- the mower charged up and was put to work.

It does take an afternoon of hammering little pegs in, testing electric circuits, and crossing fingers on occasion, but you can do it on your own. Just try to think it through a little bit more than I did!

Operation of the Gardena Robotic Lawn Mower

The mower runs on a daily programme, which can be varied through the slightly confusing on-board menu system. Be prepared to keep the instructions to hand for the first few weeks, as you'll be fine-tuning things like the time of day the mower should operate, and the number of times it follows the cable to the end before starting a run rather than just setting off in a random direction from the base.

And, the mower is governed by randomness.

It sets off when its charged, but pretty randomly, in a random direction, and changes that direction by a random amount whenever it hits an obstacle, or reaches the boundary perimeter wire.

Repairing the perimeter wire is also part of the ongoing operation and maintenance of these kinds of robotic mower, and it is a bit of hassle. Here's a tip: make sure you keep a long piece of single-core wire handy for troubleshooting, and don't bury the wire intentionally; just let the grass grow over it, or cover it with thin paving stones that are absolutely level with respect to the lawn.

The reason for this is that fault finding requires connecting one end of the cable to the base unit, and then hooking the other end to various points on the perimeter until you get a green light.

After the first few times, it gets a lot easier; but for that first time -- make sure you have wire handy, as well as a knife to scrape a little plastic off the perimeter wire, a crocodile clip to connect the wire to the perimeter cable, and some electrical tape to fix it up after...

Parts that Failed on the Lawn Mower

The first item in this category -- blades -- isn't really failure. You need to change the blades every so often.

Tell tail signs that the blades need replacing are:

  • Wobbling mower caused by uneven weight distribution (one might be broken);
  • Unusual noise;
  • Grass tips going brown (unevenly cut; more torn than cleanly cropped).
Luckily, removing them is child's play; but don't let a child near them because they're sharp! They just unscrew from the underside, and the packs of replacement blades come with new screws and full instructions.

Then, the wheels came off. Actually, that's not true. What happened was the rubber came off, and the wheels stopped gripping (this was after 3 seasons use, with no over-wintering). The replacements have a solid, moulded tread, so they'll last for the rest of the product's lifetime.

Also this year, the dampers broke. The rubber perished, and they stopped preventing the outer bumper from bashing against the collision detection system, as discussed here.

Other than these few points, which encourage me to take much better care of the mower (i.e. cleaning it and overwintering it properly), the last three seasons have been trouble-free.

Summary - Should You Buy a Gardena R40Li Robotic Lawn Mower?

Here's the thing -- I can't answer that, because I have no idea whether your lawn qualifies. However, if you hate following your mechanical mower around a pretty standard lawn, then I'd certainly consider it.

Thursday, 20 October 2016

The Gardena R40Li Bumps Up Against A Problem...

So, having swapped out the rubber-tread wheels for nice, new shiny plastic ones (see: And Then, The Wheels Came Off!) the next bits that have failed are the two rear rubber dampers. These are going to need replacing, but first, let's take a moment to look at the symptoms and probable cause.

Before we do that, I'd encourage anyone that has the Gardena r40Li, Flymo 1200R or Husqvarna 305 to download the following exploded parts diagram from the Gardena web site:


And, whilst you're perusing it, and probably going "Ah, that's what that bit is!" at the same time, remember that we've had the r40Li since 2013, and this is only the second repair that we've had to do. Yes, I've changed the blades a couple of times per season -- thanks to the kids, the grass is littered with twigs -- but this is only the second major bit of work I've had to do.

This is despite the fact that I'm not the best at cleaning, or winterising the robot mower, which is where I suspect the cause of the current problems lie.

The Odd Symptoms of Bumper Failure


On the face of it, I should have realised straight away that something was amiss.

The mower would stop, mid-mow, for no reason, and then reverse. Then, it would turn and head off  in a direction, before stopping again, reversing, turning and trying to get going in a number of different directions before giving up.

Having turned itself off, a restart listed a "collision detection failure" a few times, before I twigged that maybe this wasn't simply a question of the mower getting stuck in a corner.

So, I picked it up.

When I did so, grasping the cover, including bumpers -- look at the diagram, p.13 -- and the chassis listed alarmingly. Normally it bobs around, suspended, as I now know, on four rubber dampers, that give it flexibility and allow for the bumper to detect collisions.

Now, with one broken, it registers a permanent list to one side, and the inevitable bumper failure with it.

What Caused the Rubber to Perish?


Both the rear dampers have perished. Possible causes that spring to mind are:
  • snails (and I'm not kidding: they eat the post!);
  • cold (changes in temperature attacks rubber like nothing else);
  • bumping into objects.
That last one is pertinent, as although the perimeter wire went in three years ago, we're still moving it around to get the best edge cutting possible. Thus, the mower spends a lot of time bumping into stone edges because the perimeter wire is just a little too close to the coping stones...

On the other hand, the amount of dead grass that I pulled out also hints that maybe that also had something to do with it.

Either way, my advice would be to:
  • clean,
  • winterise,
  • avoid snails,
  • place the perimeter wire a good distance away from any coping stones...
For readers with the same issue, the parts are numbers 574 46 91-02, and they cost around 7.50 EUR each plus delivery. Much less than the wheels; and I'll let you know how I get on swapping them out with the damaged ones.

The verdict? Still recommended!

Tuesday, 19 July 2016

Is This Just The Most Expensive Anti-Mole & Auto-Mulching Device Ever?

It's been a while (3 years) since I received the best time-saving gift ever, in my opinion.

Had I listened to the naysayers, my friends and colleagues included, I would have been gearing myself up for a life spent hunting for perimeter wire breaks, changing spinning blades, unclogging the mechanism, replacing batteries, fixing electrical shorts, etc. etc.

In fact, the Husqvarna (sold also under the Gardena and Flymo brands) robotic lawnmower that I have has required less corrective maintenance than the old walk behind Briggs & Stratton powered mower that I still haven't had the heart to throw away.

That mower had issues ranging from a continuous problem with the traction drive belt (it's a heavy thing, and having it pull itself was a very desirable feature!) to a blade that was nearly impossible to take off, sharpen, and once put back never spun evenly, threatening to tear the engine off the plastic chassis!

Next to these issues, replacing the wheels when one began to fall apart, and regular blade replacement fade into the background, and both tasks are extraordinarily easy to complete. No expensive over-wintering costs, either, or replacing the engine oil, or any other of the messy jobs that you usually associate with lawn mower ownership.

However; there are a few things that I've noticed in the last three years, and are worth pointing out.

No More Moles!

The first thing that comes to mind goes back to a comment to a comment that I made back in 2014: to do with rodents eating the wire. At the time, one of my readers had pointed out that his Honda robotic lawnmower was suffering because foxes were eating through the guide wire.

My answer was to bury it deeper, thereby protecting it from ground level interference, but not from moles, which I also assumed would find the wire from time to time.

How wrong can you be?

It turns out (and this is just anecdotal - if anyone can back it up I'd be interested to hear their stories) that the number of moles in the lawn area, as evidenced by the (lack of) molehills has dropped to pretty much zero.

We used to have an issue with moles, and in the past I'd even installed one of those mole stop devices which send a subterranean pulse to warn the little blighters off, but it broke and never got replaced. 

Needless to say, the moles came back.

With the robotic lawnmower installed, however, they seem to have gone away again. I know they're in the area, because the field has been attacked, as have the neighbours' lawns (albeit to a lesser extent than before), but within our perimeter wire -- nothing.

There's a couple of explanations I can think of:
  • the irregular noise of the mower mowing creates vibrations (like the mole stop devices) that scare them away, or;
  • the electric fields made by the perimeter wire and guide wire are keeping the moles at bay.
Either way, the lawn looks better for not having any mole hills, and being greener thanks to the continuous mulching that tales place thanks to the mower's regular operation and small cutting length.

The Grass is Greener on All Sides

Just a small note here, but we have noticed an improvement (and being smart after the fact I wish I'd taken photos!) in the quality of the lawns. They are greener and more lush, presumably down to the mulching.

My walk-behind mower actually had a mulching blade fitted because I'm pretty lazy and didn't want to have to (a) empty the grass box somewhere, and (b) dispose of the grass. So, I just let the blade spin, reduce the grass clippings to dust, and let them fall where they were.

However, for this to be effective you need to mow the lawn every few days in the summer; especially because, a bit like hair, if you cut it regularly and take care of it, a lawn tends to grow faster!

Did I mention that I was lazy?

I'll admit it: to the cynic, this sounds like an expensive anti-mole and auto-mulching device, but the net effect is a healthier lawn that looks great.

My next project is to fit a couple of cameras so you can see it in action: you might even get to see it scare off a cat!

Thursday, 24 September 2015

The Robotic Lawn Mower Perimeter Wire Revisited...

Fitting a perimeter wire often requires breaking and re-connecting individual cables together; and when you buy a robotic lawn mower, they come with a selection of appropriate connectors. These, however, are quickly used up, and especially if the wire breaks (which it will do), leading to a hunt for replacement connectors.

Perimeter Wire & Guide Wire Breakage

For robot mowers that use perimeter wires, there are usually two ways that the wires are used:

  • as a boundary for the work area;
  • to guide the mower to the charging unit.

While any wire break is irritating, breaks in the boundary wire present more of a headache than the guide wire, as it involves investigating the whole loop. The instructions for the Gardena 40Li / Flymo 1200R show that there are three connection points on the base: two for the boundary wire and one for the guide wire.

There's also a light on the base (where the mower 'docks' -- you need to take it out to see the light) which has several states. States related to the boundary and guide wires are:

  • Green -- all okay;
  • Blue flashing -- break in the boundary wire;
  • Yellow flashing -- break in the guide wire.

Fixing the guide wire is easy enough, as you can trace it fairly easily (I made a plan of my own installation!), and splice the wires together.
Splice Clips

To do this, I use a splice clip, pictured here on the right, which costs about 2.5 EUR for 20 (less than 4 GBP) delivered, from online retailer Banggood.

These might not be water protected like the 3M ones that came with my Gardena 40Li, but they do the job adequately, and are a lot better than the 'sugar cube' type blocks that I was using previously, which tended to rust.

These clips can also be used to repair the boundary wire, once you know where the break is!

The instructions for doing this can be a bit confusing, but the diagrams in the user guide are pretty self-explanatory. However, since they require plugging a flying wire into the base unit, and then using it to test ever-increasing sections of the perimeter wire, I found using a terminal and spade connector made things easier.

I found these on Banggood at the same time as the splice clips (click here), for less than £2 per pack of 5. One of the 'spades'can be attached to the end of the flying wire, of which the other end is plugged into the base, in place of the regular other end of the boundary wire.

Terminal/Spade Crimp Clips
The t-connection bits end up on the boundary wire -- there being no way to take them off -- but are useful each time there's an issue.

As long as you remember (or write down) where they are, you can troubleshoot that much more easily, as well as 'shorting' between two points if you want to limit your robotic mower for some reason.

To do that, all you need is a bit of wire, the right length, with a spade at each end, and two points on the perimeter wire with a t-connector between which to put the flying wire. Now, when the mower approaches it, it will treat the new wire as if it is the boundary wire.

Simple!

Thursday, 17 September 2015

...And Then the Wheels Came Off!

It sounds like the punchline to a bad joke, but what do you do when the wheels come off your Gardena robotic lawnmower? The answer is simple, if a little long-winded: go back to the retailer and ask them to order new ones...

The Problem

The Gardena 40Li, Flymo 1200R, and Husqvarna 305 all look remarkably similar. In fact, I'd put money on the fact that they're all made by the same company, to the same design, which I'm fairly confident is Husqvarna itself.

To my knowledge, all of these share the same kind of wheels: a plastic hub and a rubber tread.

And here's the problem. After nearly 2 years of unbroken service (aside from over-wintering), my Gardena 40Li's wheels have come off.

Actually, it's just the rubber tread that has become worn out, and I found it lying on the damp lawn, with the poor mower comically pirouetting with one tread-less wheel being dragged around by the other, rubberised one.

The solution ought to have been simple -- in this day and age, surely it's possible to order Husqvarna parts online? Unfortunately, it proved to be a bit more tricky than I'd thought.

Out With the Old Wheels

Without the rubber tyres, not only can the mower not mow efficiently, but it also can't dock itself for charging, since the designers decided that the best way to achieve this would be to reverse the mowers onto the outdoor charging stand.

This means that they have to spin around (always turning the same way) and by coincidence, it looks rather as if it's the outside wheel that has come off worse and eventually failed.

So, repair is out of the question. De-rubbering the wheels is out of the question. Perhaps there's a DIY solution (let me know in the comments thread!) but the most obvious option is to replace the rubber treads.

In With the New Wheels

However, it seems that someone on the design team has realised their error with the wheels, and rubber treads aren't available, but nice, shiny, moulded plastic (with treads) wheels are.

They cost me around 25 EUR from the dealer, for a pair, and took a while to arrive -- they were permanently out of stock at the central stockists -- but when they did, they proved easy to remove and replace.

If you look at yours, you'll see that there are three torque type screws to remove, per wheel, which can be a bit tricky, due to the angles, but it can be achieved without dismantling the mower itself. This may not be the case for the original Husqvarna 305, but the Flymo 1200R and Gardena 40Li succumb to the direct approach easily!

The new wheels came without screws or washers, so you'll want to keep those and not throw them away when you dismantle the old wheels.

Besides the blades, and the occasional accident with the perimeter wire, this is the first 'major' part of the mower I've had to replace in 2 years, which makes it an immediate improvement over the old Wolf Garden manual motor-mower I used before, which suffered wheel-failure (traction belt) in the first year, and needed to be annually maintained by the local dealer to keep it working properly!

The next thing I expect to go will be the battery; I'm not sure what the lifespan of these is supposed to be, but we've already noticed extending charge cycles, and diminishing mowing times. Of course, without an actual measurement/download facility, that's anecdotal, but to be expected.

Still, being able to change the wheels myself, and as easily as changing the blades (despite having to shop-order them) removes another of my initial concerns about owning a robotic mower.

Tuesday, 8 October 2013

What Are the Differences Between the Major Robotic Lawn Mower Brands

Most robotic lawnmowers operate on the same basic principles with the same key features:

  • mulching blades (small amount of grass cut, drops onto the lawn)
  • powerful wheels (to deal with slopes)
  • sensors (to avoid obstacles)
  • guide wire (to keep within one or more zones)

However, within these principles there is scope for quite a lot of variation, and some of the variations serve to differentiate the models on offer.

Of course, as always, one of the biggest differentiating factors is price. Across the ranges, prices can triple, so it's worth knowing what you are (potentially) getting for your money.

Different Blades

Underneath any lawn mower, be it a Flymo hovering mower, or a Briggs and Stratton powered petrol guzzling traditional push around mower, there are one or more blades.

Traditional mowers are built to cut through long grass that has either been neglected over the off-season, or needs cutting every week (and only gets cut once a week) with the clippings being taken off to be disposed of.

Robotic mowers are designed for one purpose - to cut automatically and regularly, and drop the grass tips down onto the lawn to mulch it; automatically providing nutrition as well as keeping the lawn trim.


Most of the mowers on the market have multiple blades, held in place by a screw, which spin around at great speed, clipping the tips of the grass, and then chopping those tips into a fine dust.

Above right, are the blades for a Bosch Indego mower, which are long and thin.

To the left are the blades from a Gardena / Husqvarna, and Flymo mower, all of which seem to be either manufactured by Husqvarna in different liveries, or made under license.

Then, there are the single blade varieties, such as those used by RoboMow models, as pictured on the right.

So, which is the best?

Naturally, each manufacturer will have their reasons, but from the point of view of the mulching process, I have an idea that the loose blades might provide a better cutting action.

However, they are also more likely to snap (it's happened twice on my Gardena/Husqvarna) and fall off. I have a sneaking suspicion that the single piece blades are less likely to fail, but more likely to do damage should they come off.

Different Wheels

There are really only two choices for wheel arrangements - thee or four wheels - but again there is a surprising amount of variety across brands. Originally, Husqvarna went with a three wheel model, with the rear single wheel being smaller, and on a pivot.

This is very similar to the Flymo wheel arrangement, pictured on the left.

It has been replaced in more recent models with a version that has the smaller wheel at the front, like the Bosch Indego, and which, like the Bosch also enters the charging station front-first as opposed to back-first like the smaller Flymo models

Different Control Styles

All mowers need to have sensors to avoid hitting obstacles (like dogs, cats or trees!) and these are usually in the form of bumpers. Bumpers are reliable in a way that, for example, an ultrasound sensor might not be.

Next to the bumpers are different remote control styles - some mowers have a control pad that lets the owner steer the mower from zone to zone, while most just take themselves to a new zone by following a guide wire.

The guide wire is accompanied by a perimeter wire, which restricts the mower to the current zone. Many manufacturers also sell a kit to add new zones, so that the mower can be used on a greater area than originally installed.

Finally, some more recent models are starting to use GPS (Global Positioning System) antennas to help map out the space that needs to be mowed, and also to make sure that the whole area has been cut.

This last is important because, like some robotic vacuum cleaners, most of the models on the market tend to mow in a random fashion, over an extended period of time, and use this to make sure that the whole lawn has been cut.

Some of the more expensive models also have other cutting modes, so that they can be adapted to different shapes of lawn. So, if you have a lawn that is (a) large and (b) has many obstacles as well as (c) being an odd shape, it's probably worth spending a bit extra to get a more clever mower.

One last differentiating factor is the charging station. While most manufacturers have spotted that this needs to be weatherproof and located outside, some of the cheaper models still have an indoor charging station and require the mower to be carried or driven from the garage to the lawn.

Clearly, in the interests of automatic mowing, and ease of use, an outdoor charging station is the way to go.

Armed with this rundown of the various different features of automatic robotic lawn mowers, you should now be ready to choose from the models on the market, and join the rest of us who can sit back and watch whilst our lawns are carefully and immaculately mowed!

Thursday, 26 September 2013

The Robomow RL 555-HD Lawnmower : A Robotic Automatic Lawnmower with a Few Issues!

Firstly, a disclaimer : I don't actually own one of these, but have spent time gathering the opinions of others, and hopefully can point out a few of the glaring omissions in the design of the mower, whilst helping out anyone who owns one (or something similar) and is having issues with it.

What we have is a re-branded Husqvarna (marketed by Gardena on the continent, and Flymo, I believe, in the UK) and, for the record, I'm pretty happy with it.
The Robomow RL 555-HD

The first issue is that the 555 needs to be indoors in order to be charged. This doesn't make sense for something that ought to be automatic in every sense. In fact, I was hard pressed to find another robotic mower that has the same requirement.

Luckily, Robomow have fixed this design fault in other models, such as the RL2000 and the aptly named City 110 (it won't mow anything bigger than a 'city' lawn!)

The 555 has, instead, a remote control that is supposed to be used to drive it out of the garage and onto the lawn. That feels a bit like pushing an old fashioned lawnmower (sorry, traditional lawnmower) out onto the lawn, and not what you'd expect from a 21st century invention.

Once on the lawn, the 555 navigates using a perimeter wire. This is the preferred method of enclosing mowing zones, and used by Bosch, Flymo, Robomow, and others. Usually it works well, but when it doesn't it's usually because there's a break in the wire.

These can be hard to track down, and there's no real substitute for going along the wire (a pain if it's been dug in) and trying to find the fault. However, that's a problem shared by all the current market leaders.

A word of advice - first check that the connectors are still plugged in okay by unplugging and re-plugging them into the base unit. Then, if that fails, change the connectors (I've left about 20 inches of cable after the plugs just so I can do that!) just to be 100% sure it's the wire, and not the plugs.

The plugs are outdoors, so it could just be that they have become full of water, eaten by pests, or otherwise damaged or moved.

The mowing action is also the same as any other automatic robotic lawnmower in that they don't pick up after themselves. They're designed to be run frequently, clipping the ends off the grass, and letting it drop down onto the lawn, thereby fertilizing it (the mulching idea.)

Now, the Robomow 555 has two issues here.

The first is that it is heavy to take from the garage to the lawn, and so having it mow every day is going to become a problem over time. Secondly, there are issues with the Robomow and wet grass, according to an Amazon review. Apparently, it doesn't cope well with it.

This could be an issue, because mulching is best done when the grass is damp, according to one of my fellow mower-owners. But, since I don't own one, I can't comment further.

All in all, the main downfall of the 555 is that it can't be charged outside, which removes one of the central pillars of the buying decision : that it be convenient. To give them credit, the manufacturer has spotted this, and other models are self-charging, outside.